Our Joy Toys
Close

Welcome!

Sign up to our e-newsletter to receive a 10% off coupon code! Redeem code at checkout.

Get FREE SHIPPING on All Orders Over $49
0 Cart
Added to Cart
    You have items in your cart
    You have 1 item in your cart
    Total
    Check Out Continue Shopping

    Butt Plugs

    Shop our variety of butt plugs from the industry's leading brands including Doc Johnson, CalExotics, Topco and more. You'll find a range of sizes and features in this category including vibrating butt plugs and remote control options.
    Collection Menu
    Classic Small Smooth Butt Plug
    Classic Small Smooth Butt Plug Doc Johnson
    $14.99
    Wendy Williams Anal Trainer Kit
    Wendy Williams Anal Trainer Kit Doc Johnson
    $32.99
    Booty Call Booty Rocker Butt Plug
    Booty Call Booty Rocker Butt Plug CalExotics
    $16.99
    Pipedream Products PD4693-23 Anal Fantasy Collection Ass-Gasm Cockring Beginners Plug
    Anal Fantasy Collection Ass-Gasm Cockring Beginners Plug Pipedream Products
    $28.99
    Mood Naughty 2 X-Large Plug - OUR JOY TOYS
    Mood Naughty 2 X-Large Plug Doc Johnson
    $38.99
    Mood Naughty 1 X-Large Plug - OUR JOY TOYS
    Mood Naughty 1 X-Large Plug Doc Johnson
    $38.99
    Mood Juicy Swirled Vibrating Plug - OUR JOY TOYS
    Mood Juicy Swirled Vibrating Plug Doc Johnson
    $62.99
    Mood Juicy Beaded Vibrating Plug - OUR JOY TOYS
    Mood Juicy Beaded Vibrating Plug Doc Johnson
    $62.99
    Mini Vibro Tease™ - OUR JOY TOYS
    Mini Vibro Tease CalExotics
    $19.99
    Icicles No. 49 - OUR JOY TOYS
    Icicles No. 49 Pipedream Products
    $66.99
    Icicles No. 47 - OUR JOY TOYS
    Icicles No. 47 Pipedream Products
    $26.99
    Icicles No. 46 - OUR JOY TOYS
    Icicles No. 46 Pipedream Products
    $28.99
    Icicles No. 44 - OUR JOY TOYS
    Icicles No. 44 Pipedream Products
    $28.99
    Icicles No. 37 - OUR JOY TOYS
    Icicles No. 37 Pipedream Products
    $34.99
    Vibrating High Intensity Probe
    Vibrating High Intensity Probe CalExotics
    $26.99
    Remoji SURFER Plug Vibe
    Remoji SURFER Plug Vibe Pico Bong
    $159.99
    Crystal Jellies Anal Initiation Kit
    Crystal Jellies Anal Initiation Kit Doc Johnson
    $26.99
    Wildfire Down & Dirty 5 Plug & Tug Cock Ring
    Wildfire Down & Dirty 5 Plug & Tug Cock Ring Topco
    $25.99
    COLT Anal Trainer Kit
    COLT Anal Trainer Kit CalExotics
    $37.99
    Booty Call Booty Vibro Kit
    Booty Call Booty Vibro Kit CalExotics
    $31.99
    Booty Call Booty Glider
    Booty Call Booty Glider CalExotics
    $22.99
    Fetish Fantasy Limited Edition Ultimate Bondage Kit
    Fetish Fantasy Limited Edition Ultimate Bondage Kit Pipedream Products
    $59.99
    Pipedream Products PD4671-00 Anal Fantasy Collection Deluxe Fantasy Kit
    Anal Fantasy Collection Deluxe Fantasy Kit Pipedream Products
    $95.99
    Doc Johnson Crystal Jellies 5" Anal Delight 0283-01-CD
    Crystal Jellies 5" Anal Delight Doc Johnson
    $16.99
    TitanMen The Hollow Butt Plug
    TitanMen The Hollow Butt Plug Doc Johnson
    $22.99
    Platinum Premium Silicone The Big End
    Platinum Premium Silicone The Big End Doc Johnson
    $39.99
    Platinum Premium Silicone Smooth Butt Plug Small
    Platinum Premium Silicone Smooth Butt Plug Small Doc Johnson
    $20.99
    Platinum Premium Silicone Smooth Butt Plug Medium
    Platinum Premium Silicone Smooth Butt Plug Medium Doc Johnson
    From $24.99
    Platinum Premium Silicone The Rocket
    Platinum Premium Silicone The Rocket Doc Johnson
    From $46.99
    Platinum Premium Silicone The Mini's Bubble Medium Plug
    Platinum Premium Silicone The Mini's Bubble Medium Plug Doc Johnson
    $24.99
    Neo Silicone Plug - OUR JOY TOYS
    Neo Silicone Plug Tantus Silicone
    $52.99
    Mood Naughty 3 3.5" Silicone Plug - OUR JOY TOYS
    Mood Naughty 3 3.5" Silicone Plug Doc Johnson
    $27.99
    Mood Naughty 2 4.5" Silicone Plug - OUR JOY TOYS
    Mood Naughty 2 4.5" Silicone Plug Doc Johnson
    $29.99
    Mood Naughty 2 3.5" Silicone Plug - OUR JOY TOYS
    Mood Naughty 2 3.5" Silicone Plug Doc Johnson
    $27.99
    Mood Naughty 2 3" Silicone Plug - OUR JOY TOYS
    Mood Naughty 2 3" Silicone Plug Doc Johnson
    $26.99
    Glo Slim Vibrating Anal Plug - DISCO - OUR JOY TOYS
    Glo Slim Vibrating Anal Plug - DISCO Doc Johnson
    $50.99
    Fetish Fantasy Series Limited Edition Butt Plug
    Fetish Fantasy Series Limited Edition Butt Plug Pipedream Products
    $13.99
    Fetish Fantasy Limited Edition Ribbed Double Trouble
    Fetish Fantasy Limited Edition Ribbed Double Trouble Pipedream Products
    $28.99
    Fetish Fantasy Gold Luv Plug - OUR JOY TOYS
    Fetish Fantasy Gold Luv Plug Pipedream Products
    $59.99
    Dr. Joel Kaplan Silicone Inflatable Plug
    Dr. Joel Kaplan Silicone Inflatable Plug CalExotics
    $38.99
    COLT XXL Pumper Plug
    COLT XXL Pumper Plug CalExotics
    $53.99
    COLT Large Pumper Plug
    COLT Large Pumper Plug CalExotics
    $38.99
    COLTHefty Probe Inflatable Butt Plug
    COLTHefty Probe Inflatable Butt Plug CalExotics
    $29.99
    COLT Expandable Butt Plug
    COLT Expandable Butt Plug CalExotics
    $49.99
    Classic Medium Butt Plug
    Classic Medium Butt Plug Doc Johnson
    $16.99
    Classic Large Smooth Butt Plug
    Classic Large Smooth Butt Plug Doc Johnson
    $20.99
    Bronco Silicone Butt Plug
    Bronco Silicone Butt Plug Tantus Silicone
    $54.99
    Pipedream Products PD4608-23 Anal Fantasy Collection Vibrating Perfect Plug
    Anal Fantasy Collection Vibrating Perfect Plug Pipedream Products
    $35.99